Hand-count errors tied to about 300 misreported votes in Mat-Su Borough election
The errors were found by the borough's canvass boards during their election review.
What you need to know:
- Election volunteers incorrectly reported vote totals this month in two Mat-Su Borough precincts. Canvass boards found and corrected the errors during their review of the Nov. 3 election results.
- The errors affected vote tallies for three borough propositions, but none would have changed the outcomes. The Mat-Su Assembly unanimously certified the results.
- Election officials also found 17 instances of missing voter signatures and nine people who voted twice. Only one ballot per voter was counted, and officials attributed the irregularities to human error rather than fraud.
- Short on time but need the local news scoop? Get free weekly news in your inbox for Mat-Su, from Mat-Su.
PALMER — Hand-count volunteers in two Mat-Su precincts incorrectly reported hundreds of votes during the borough’s Nov. 3 election, officials said this week.
The Matanuska-Susitna Borough canvass boards found and corrected the errors during their nine-day review of election results, officials told the Mat-Su Assembly during an election certification meeting Tuesday.
The discrepancies affected 281 votes across two of the borough’s 40 precincts, officials said. Had they gone unnoticed, none of the errors would have changed the outcome of the election, according to election results data.
The assembly voted unanimously to approve the election results.
Mat-Su is the only borough in the state that requires ballots to be counted by hand.
A 2022 Mat-Su law requires all borough votes to be counted by hand. A measure approved last year also prohibits the borough from using any electronic assistance during vote counts, including paper-counting machines that tally the total number of ballots submitted but do not tabulate votes.
In Precinct 25-310 Greater Palmer, the canvass board recounted all votes because the recorded count did not match the number of ballots issued, officials said. Voting for the precinct is held at the Palmer Depot.
“The total number of ballots was 465, but some of the totals that were reported by the hand count officials were above 465,” said Helen Mielke, who spoke on behalf of the canvass board. “We ultimately decided to recount the whole entire precinct.”
For example, the precinct’s Election Day hand count for Proposition A, which changed school board terms from three to four years, was 175 yes and 276 no. But the board’s recount found the correct count to be 185 yes and 266 no, Mielke said. For Proposition B, which would have added a 5% tax to alcohol sales, the precinct's count was 288 yes. The board’s recount found the correct number to be 188 yes, she said.
In Precinct 30-580 Houston, where voting is held at Houston City Hall, Election Day counters transposed the Proposition C “yes” and “no” vote tallies on the results log. Instead of correctly recording the vote as 126 in favor and 297 against, the sheet listed 297 in favor and 126 against. Proposition C proposed a $75,000 property tax exemption for owner-occupied homes, paired with a 1% sales tax.
The board opted to recount the entire precinct to check for other errors, Mielke said. Board members noticed the transcription error because support for the proposal in that precinct was the opposite of what it was elsewhere, she said.
“One of the canvass board members had been looking at the numbers for all of the yes/no votes, and she thought it was weird that this one was transposed to a different yes/no total comparatively to the rest of the precincts,” she said.
Voters boroughwide approved Proposition A, with 20,052 votes in favor and 19,655 against. Proposition B failed, with 23,049 votes against and 17,320 in favor. Proposition C also failed, with 25,692 votes against and 13,753 in favor.

The board also found 17 instances of ballots issued without proper signatures recorded in the voter registry at precincts at the former Meadow Lakes Elementary School building and Church on the Rock in Palmer. Those were due to election volunteer error and are not considered voter fraud, Mielke said in an interview after the meeting.
The canvass board also found that nine individuals voted twice. Only one of the two votes is counted, Borough Clerk Lonnie McKechnie told the Assembly. All double votes found this year involved a combination of early or absentee mail-in ballots and Election Day votes, she said in an interview. Had they been tallied, none of the double votes would have changed any final election outcome.

Limited instances of double voting occur during each election cycle, she said. The voters are typically elderly and may be confused by the overlap of state and borough ballots and voting for the borough’s cities, which is held in early October, she said.
Such voters are sent a letter informing them of their double vote and warning against casting two ballots again.
Evidence of any individual voting twice on Election Day is referred to the Department of Public Safety for a voter fraud investigation, McKechnie said. No such instances were found during this year’s election, she said.
The Mat-Su Borough uses two canvass boards with a combined nine members to oversee election results. The boards work with Mat-Su Borough clerk’s office staff to tally absentee votes, review and count questioned and special needs ballots, and review all election results. The boards split their work time so ballots are reviewed as quickly as possible without requiring any one group of volunteers to work days, evenings and weekends, Mielke said.
-- Contact Amy Bushatz at contact@matsusentinel.com