Voters reject recall of Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington

Carrington will stay in office until the city's regular election in October.

Voters reject recall of Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington
A campaign sign posted in Palmer on May 20, 2025, asked residents to vote "no" in a recall election for Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington. The signs are also the subject of an Alaska Public Offices Commission complaint because they do not list the top three contributors of the ballot group that purchased them. (Amy Bushatz/Mat-Su Sentinel)

What you need to know:

  • Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington will remain in office after voters rejected a recall effort in a special election Tuesday with a vote of 222 to 176.
  • Recall proponents alleged that Carrington overstepped his authority by hiring an outside attorney without City Council approval. Carrington defended his actions, citing legal uncertainties involving a former city manager.
  • Carrington will remain in office until the city's October regular election.

PALMER — Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington will stay in office after voters rejected his recall during a special election held early this week.

The recall was defeated 222 to 176, according to unofficial election results released early Friday afternoon.

The tally includes 202 early, absentee and special needs ballots and 196 votes cast on Tuesday. About 8% of the city’s registered voters participated in the election.

“This is what I had hoped for. I think that common sense is still the majority in Palmer, and I think the voters are reflecting that,” Carrington said in an interview Friday following the results update.

Officials with a “Recall Steve Carrington” special-interest group thanked voters for their participation.

“I want to say thank you so much for everyone who voted,” said Jackie Goforth, the group’s chairperson. “The citizens of Palmer have made the decision. That’s how democracy works — it’s perfectly fine.”

Advertisement

Preliminary results released after polls closed Tuesday showed recall supporters winning by a narrow margin of 99 to 97. That count did not include early or absentee ballots.

Election results will be certified during a regular Palmer City Council meeting scheduled for next week.

Proponents of the recall alleged that Carrington is guilty of official misconduct because he overstepped his authority when he hired an outside attorney last year without first obtaining City Council approval.

A sign supporting the recall of Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington
A sign supporting the recall of Palmer Mayor Steve Carrington sits next to the Matanuska River Park trailhead in Palmer on May 20, 2025. (Amy Bushatz/Mat-Su Sentinel)

Carrington said he authorized the agreement due to “legal uncertainties” surrounding accusations against former Palmer City Manager Stephen Jellie, according to a statement included on the special election ballots.

Carrington will remain in office until the city’s regular election in October. He does not plan to run for reelection, he said.

Alaska state law prohibits filing a new application to recall Carrington for six months.

A complaint filed by Goforth with the Alaska Public Offices Commission on May 7 alleges that a ballot proposition group registered as NO Recall for Palmer MayorSteve.com and chaired by Carrington failed to properly disclose financial contributors on campaign signage.

The commission denied a request for an expedited hearing during a virtual special meeting on the matter Tuesday afternoon. A nonexpedited hearing will be scheduled for a later date, officials said during that meeting.

-- Contact Amy Bushatz at contact@matsusentinel.com

         
         
Mat-Su Sentinel ad

Sign up for Mat-Su Sentinel, our free email newsletter

Get the latest headlines right in your inbox